It's finally here! The results for the SMWCentral Level Design Challenge 2010 are finally in! It's 6AM local time so please excuse any and all incoherence on my part. Insomnia is a bitch.
Submissions Thread
Discussion Thread
So first off congratulations to all the participants. This year we had 124 people submit an entry. That's an amazing number! If this trend of doubling the previous year's number of entries continues, I'm not looking forward to judging next year!
Second, a great thanks to our judges. This year we had four judges. Myself and SNN were known from the start of the judging period, Supertails revealed himself a couple days ago, and our 4th judge, the "mystery judge," was SyStemkraSh. Thanks to all of you for putting up with the enormous amount of entries we received this year.
Due to delays and not wanting to wait any longer to post results, SyStemkraSh's scores have been thrown out. His scoring was only 2/3 finished and so as not to skew results by averaging in what he had completed, we all decided this was the best course of action. Final scoring is based on the average of mine, SNN's and Supertails' individual scores for that level.
"He's still talking about formalities, I just want to see the results!"
You're right about that random speaker, so since I don't know what else to preface with, I guess it's time to get to the main event.
The results of the SMWCentral Level Design Challenge 2010!
First Place
Lynnes - Forever Factory (47.50/50.00)
Second Place
superwiidude - Mountain Fortress (46.00/50.00)
Aqualakitu - Lunar Island Exploration (46.00/50.00)
Third Place
Ddoomm10 - Mario's Endless Adventure (45.17/50.00)
Honorary Mention (4th Place)
Zildjian - Mario Takes a Stroll (44.83/50.00)
reghrhre - Mystical Orb Search (44.83/50.00)
Agent Q - Watch Tower Duke-Out (44.83/50.00)
Honorary Mention (5th Place)
Darky - Muncher Sphere (43.67/50.00)
-----
This concludes the winners and honorary mentions. The rest of the places are as follows. (Note: For those that didn't place 5th or higher, I'm not including the level names for their entries so as to make this post not take any longer than it already is taking to write. Sue me later for being lazy.)
-----
RedToonLink - (43.33/50.00)
Dotsarecool - (43.33/50.00)
Hadron - (43.00/50.00)
Senjan - (42.83/50.00)
Chikane - (42.50/50.00)
TRS - (42.33/50.00)
Counterfeit - (42.33/50.00)
TOS - (42.17/50.00)
yogui - (42.00/50.00)
cyphermur9t - (41.83/50.00)
Marioman - (41.83/50.00)
GN - (41.67/50.00)
Kristian - (41.33/50.00)
keckcellent - (41.17/50.00)
Tails_155 - (41.00/50.00)
Neutron - (41.00/50.00)
PercentN - (40.83/50.00)
LunarYoshi - (40.50/50.00)
Zmann - (40.50/50.00)
Riolu180 - (40.50/50.00)
TLMB - (40.50/50.00)
Master S - (40.17/50.00)
DaxterSpeed - (40.17/50.00)
MoogleEmperor - (39.83/50.00)
TheGamer - (39.50/50.00)
Z. Raffle tikt - (39.33/50.00)
Brad172 - (39.17/50.00)
Argumentable - (38.83/50.00)
Hach - (38.67/50.00)
dottedboy - (38.50/50.00)
MajorasMask9 - (38.17/50.00)
Whoamme - (38.17/50.00)
RealLink - (38.00/50.00)
imamelia - (37.67/50.00)
Randoguy101 - (37.50/50.00)
PowerStrike - (36.83/50.00)
Patgangster - (36.83/50.00)
Rocket Sparkster - (36.83/50.00)
losoall - (36.67/50.00)
jesus - (36.67/50.00)
SomeGuy - (36.33/50.00)
jur132 - (36.17/50.00)
Darkdata - (36.17/50.00)
Lu-Kaz - (36.17/50.00)
MAGUSANDMETROIDFTW - (36.17/50.00)
E-Man - (36.00/50.00)
---smwExpert--- - (36.00/50.00)
DarthYoshi492 - (35.67/50.00)
Time Traveler - (35.67/50.00)
MarioFan22 - (35.67/50.00)
arnpoly - (35.67/50.00)
HuFlungDu - (35.50/50.00)
Creatorofchaos - (35.50/50.00)
hebesphenomegacorona - (35.33/50.00)
Snifit - (35.33/50.00)
Mariowings77 - (34.83/50.00)
tatanga - (34.83/50.00)
K3fka - (34.67/50.00)
BlackEagle766 - (34.50/50.00)
ToasterTank - (34.17/50.00)
booblock - (34.00/50.00)
x-treme - (34.00/50.00)
CCF9Unite - (33.83/50.00)
sky_blue_wiggler - (33.67/50.00)
Dashie - (33.00/50.00)
Rayman Man - (33.00/50.00)
Luigi Pikachu - (31.67/50.00)
FUGGNUTZ - (31.50/50.00)
Lunar Rico - (31.17/50.00)
Miguel20 - (30.83/50.00)
Diddy Kong - (30.00/50.00)
kirbyeatsbomberman - (29.83/50.00)
boredman - (29.00/50.00)
Snowshoe - (29.00/50.00)
mootbooxle - (29.00/50.00)
Elite Goomba Hacker - (28.67/50.00)
GanonTEK - (28.50/50.00)
mariocool1999 - (28.17/50.00)
joeblevins123 - (27.67/50.00)
Bowser's Level Designer - (27.67/50.00)
Triple Q - (27.33/50.00)
Best Video Gamer - (27.17/50.00)
mariofan1000 - (26.33/50.00)
10204307 - (26.33/50.00)
everest700 - (26.00/50.00)
Akhenderson - (26.00/50.00)
vindew332 - (25.00/50.00)
xman0444 - (24.67/50.00)
super pokemon world - (23.83/50.00)
Immortality - (23.33/50.00)
GoldRogerPirateKing - (23.33/50.00)
PwndGames - (21.67/50.00)
TiersWTF - (21.00/50.00)
Wizard the Wizzisential - (20.67/50.00)
Smallhacker - (19.83/50.00)
kurosaga - (19.33/50.00)
Posiedien3 - (19.00/50.00)
jailerman - (18.50/50.00)
neosaver - (18.33/50.00)
MalcolmBellman38 - (16.83/50.00)
DragonManGuyDude - (4.00/50.00)
-----
The follow users were unfortunately disqualified due to various conditions such as bad patches and graphical changes.
BBkaizo
DemXiX
Fakescaper
Doownayr89
Playnoweverybody
Desert-Fox
Pikerchu13
HighVoltageGamer
masterdud
swamp cecil
LaularuKyrumo
mrwannabe
VideoGuy
-----
The following two users requested early removal from the contest.
BloodyToothBrush
Toad8642
-----
So there are your winners and everyone else who participated in this contest. For individual score breakdowns, I will refer you to the judgment text files. If you are in the first 86 entries to the contest, SyStemkraSh has rated your levels so you can look at hsi scores as well.
FirePhoenix's Judgments
SNN's Judgments
Supertails' Judgments
SyStemkraSh's Judgments (unfinished)
For a more thorough comparison of all the entries, including a few statistics, here is the Excel Workbook (97-2003) that I used to compile all the scores. You can also see SyStemkraSh's scores on the side, however, they do not factor into the final score column.
LDC2010 Scoring Final.xls (Excel 97-2003 Workbook)
I think that about wraps up the results. Once more, congratulations to the winners, thanks to all the entrants, major thanks to the judges and thanks to the rest of the website for waiting patiently for the scores even though they were delayed about a week.
If you see any mistakes in the results anywhere please let me know. Early morning is not usually the best time to do this sort of stuff.
Submissions Thread
Discussion Thread
So first off congratulations to all the participants. This year we had 124 people submit an entry. That's an amazing number! If this trend of doubling the previous year's number of entries continues, I'm not looking forward to judging next year!
Second, a great thanks to our judges. This year we had four judges. Myself and SNN were known from the start of the judging period, Supertails revealed himself a couple days ago, and our 4th judge, the "mystery judge," was SyStemkraSh. Thanks to all of you for putting up with the enormous amount of entries we received this year.
Due to delays and not wanting to wait any longer to post results, SyStemkraSh's scores have been thrown out. His scoring was only 2/3 finished and so as not to skew results by averaging in what he had completed, we all decided this was the best course of action. Final scoring is based on the average of mine, SNN's and Supertails' individual scores for that level.
"He's still talking about formalities, I just want to see the results!"
You're right about that random speaker, so since I don't know what else to preface with, I guess it's time to get to the main event.
The results of the SMWCentral Level Design Challenge 2010!
First Place
Lynnes - Forever Factory (47.50/50.00)
Second Place
superwiidude - Mountain Fortress (46.00/50.00)
Aqualakitu - Lunar Island Exploration (46.00/50.00)
Third Place
Ddoomm10 - Mario's Endless Adventure (45.17/50.00)
Honorary Mention (4th Place)
Zildjian - Mario Takes a Stroll (44.83/50.00)
reghrhre - Mystical Orb Search (44.83/50.00)
Agent Q - Watch Tower Duke-Out (44.83/50.00)
Honorary Mention (5th Place)
Darky - Muncher Sphere (43.67/50.00)
-----
This concludes the winners and honorary mentions. The rest of the places are as follows. (Note: For those that didn't place 5th or higher, I'm not including the level names for their entries so as to make this post not take any longer than it already is taking to write. Sue me later for being lazy.)
-----
RedToonLink - (43.33/50.00)
Dotsarecool - (43.33/50.00)
Hadron - (43.00/50.00)
Senjan - (42.83/50.00)
Chikane - (42.50/50.00)
TRS - (42.33/50.00)
Counterfeit - (42.33/50.00)
TOS - (42.17/50.00)
yogui - (42.00/50.00)
cyphermur9t - (41.83/50.00)
Marioman - (41.83/50.00)
GN - (41.67/50.00)
Kristian - (41.33/50.00)
keckcellent - (41.17/50.00)
Tails_155 - (41.00/50.00)
Neutron - (41.00/50.00)
PercentN - (40.83/50.00)
LunarYoshi - (40.50/50.00)
Zmann - (40.50/50.00)
Riolu180 - (40.50/50.00)
TLMB - (40.50/50.00)
Master S - (40.17/50.00)
DaxterSpeed - (40.17/50.00)
MoogleEmperor - (39.83/50.00)
TheGamer - (39.50/50.00)
Z. Raffle tikt - (39.33/50.00)
Brad172 - (39.17/50.00)
Argumentable - (38.83/50.00)
Hach - (38.67/50.00)
dottedboy - (38.50/50.00)
MajorasMask9 - (38.17/50.00)
Whoamme - (38.17/50.00)
RealLink - (38.00/50.00)
imamelia - (37.67/50.00)
Randoguy101 - (37.50/50.00)
PowerStrike - (36.83/50.00)
Patgangster - (36.83/50.00)
Rocket Sparkster - (36.83/50.00)
losoall - (36.67/50.00)
jesus - (36.67/50.00)
SomeGuy - (36.33/50.00)
jur132 - (36.17/50.00)
Darkdata - (36.17/50.00)
Lu-Kaz - (36.17/50.00)
MAGUSANDMETROIDFTW - (36.17/50.00)
E-Man - (36.00/50.00)
---smwExpert--- - (36.00/50.00)
DarthYoshi492 - (35.67/50.00)
Time Traveler - (35.67/50.00)
MarioFan22 - (35.67/50.00)
arnpoly - (35.67/50.00)
HuFlungDu - (35.50/50.00)
Creatorofchaos - (35.50/50.00)
hebesphenomegacorona - (35.33/50.00)
Snifit - (35.33/50.00)
Mariowings77 - (34.83/50.00)
tatanga - (34.83/50.00)
K3fka - (34.67/50.00)
BlackEagle766 - (34.50/50.00)
ToasterTank - (34.17/50.00)
booblock - (34.00/50.00)
x-treme - (34.00/50.00)
CCF9Unite - (33.83/50.00)
sky_blue_wiggler - (33.67/50.00)
Dashie - (33.00/50.00)
Rayman Man - (33.00/50.00)
Luigi Pikachu - (31.67/50.00)
FUGGNUTZ - (31.50/50.00)
Lunar Rico - (31.17/50.00)
Miguel20 - (30.83/50.00)
Diddy Kong - (30.00/50.00)
kirbyeatsbomberman - (29.83/50.00)
boredman - (29.00/50.00)
Snowshoe - (29.00/50.00)
mootbooxle - (29.00/50.00)
Elite Goomba Hacker - (28.67/50.00)
GanonTEK - (28.50/50.00)
mariocool1999 - (28.17/50.00)
joeblevins123 - (27.67/50.00)
Bowser's Level Designer - (27.67/50.00)
Triple Q - (27.33/50.00)
Best Video Gamer - (27.17/50.00)
mariofan1000 - (26.33/50.00)
10204307 - (26.33/50.00)
everest700 - (26.00/50.00)
Akhenderson - (26.00/50.00)
vindew332 - (25.00/50.00)
xman0444 - (24.67/50.00)
super pokemon world - (23.83/50.00)
Immortality - (23.33/50.00)
GoldRogerPirateKing - (23.33/50.00)
PwndGames - (21.67/50.00)
TiersWTF - (21.00/50.00)
Wizard the Wizzisential - (20.67/50.00)
Smallhacker - (19.83/50.00)
kurosaga - (19.33/50.00)
Posiedien3 - (19.00/50.00)
jailerman - (18.50/50.00)
neosaver - (18.33/50.00)
MalcolmBellman38 - (16.83/50.00)
DragonManGuyDude - (4.00/50.00)
-----
The follow users were unfortunately disqualified due to various conditions such as bad patches and graphical changes.
BBkaizo
DemXiX
Fakescaper
Doownayr89
Playnoweverybody
Desert-Fox
Pikerchu13
HighVoltageGamer
masterdud
swamp cecil
LaularuKyrumo
mrwannabe
VideoGuy
-----
The following two users requested early removal from the contest.
BloodyToothBrush
Toad8642
-----
So there are your winners and everyone else who participated in this contest. For individual score breakdowns, I will refer you to the judgment text files. If you are in the first 86 entries to the contest, SyStemkraSh has rated your levels so you can look at hsi scores as well.
FirePhoenix's Judgments
SNN's Judgments
Supertails' Judgments
SyStemkraSh's Judgments (unfinished)
For a more thorough comparison of all the entries, including a few statistics, here is the Excel Workbook (97-2003) that I used to compile all the scores. You can also see SyStemkraSh's scores on the side, however, they do not factor into the final score column.
LDC2010 Scoring Final.xls (Excel 97-2003 Workbook)
I think that about wraps up the results. Once more, congratulations to the winners, thanks to all the entrants, major thanks to the judges and thanks to the rest of the website for waiting patiently for the scores even though they were delayed about a week.
If you see any mistakes in the results anywhere please let me know. Early morning is not usually the best time to do this sort of stuff.