Originally posted by Anorakun
Uh, that's something, I guess. It's way too industrial to fit an ice cave. Also, the metal noises in the background are really loud that distracts me a bit from the main melody.
Uhh, well, I'll start by saying that those "metal noises" are supposed to be a sample of a fairly distinct sound of ice being shattered (with some wind added to it btw, which is technically why the drums are so "noisy" in the first place), which, while it isn't that obvious at first (especially with everything else in the mix), I legit don't know why you thought that considering that, again, this sound is extremely specific, and shouldn't be hard to spot if you pay close enough attention to it... maybe listen to the track a bit closer before judging it or something???
Originally posted by MarioFanGamer
Icy... but not cavy. Mega Man is a game about robots and a lot of stages are partially industrial. Not quite a fan of the music too.
Well, while I would say this one in particular is more subjective than anything, I still can't help but think this statement is just ridiculous IMO; like, do you hear anything that sounds industrial here (outside of the drums, which I already talked about), because I don't see it... I can understand the cave part tho, but honestly I still don't think this deserved such a low score, especially since the port was fine enough on it's own :V
Again, not trying to be rude to anyone in specific, but honestly while that the voting process for these contests already have a ton of questionable rankings and commentary, this was a bit too much for me to bear IMO, especially considering how much I actually enjoyed how this port turned out; meh, whatever, I'm willing to look past it anyway, but yeah, I just had to vent a little bit... congrats to the winners btw!