Originally posted by MajorasMask9
Because the mafia falseclaiming doctor would have been a bad play. Obviously the mafia knew there was a Doctor alive when EvilGuy died and was revealed as the Cop (since they have a Roleblocker, meaning Row 2 roles were used.) By falseclaiming Doctor there would be a Doctor counterclaim by the real Doctor, and even if we lynched that doctor, we'd have a confirmed guilty player since we would then know he wasn't the Doctor. I really don't think it would be like you for you (as a townie) to vote for someone who's claiming Doctor of all things.
And your vote wasn't just a countervote. You voted for him after you "saw him slip up" and you latched at that piece of evidence hard. As if you no longer cared that there was a possibility he was the Doctor.
This. You completely missed my point from both rounds.
You say "By falseclaiming Doctor there would be a Doctor counterclaim by the real Doctor"
As I've said repeatedly (and I'm really confused as to WHY you've glossed over this point twice now, because I'm pretty sure you know how this setup works) last round, the only role confirmed was the cop. The mafia didn't HAVE to have a roleblocker at that point. Until BMM died and was revealed as the cop, there were two possible setups. (which I even mentioned at the start of the round, "either Townie + Cop + Mafia Goon, or Mafia Roleblocker + Cop + Doctor.").
In the former possible setup, the mafia would have KNOWN there was no doctor,
so no, there would not be a counterclaim by the real doctor. In that case, BMM could be Mafia claiming doctor (as doctor is a possible role) when in the actual setup, no doctor exists.
As the town we're unable to prove that claim true or false, regardless of if its uncounterclaimed. Which brings me back to my point of it being 50/50. And as BMM was acting scummy, it wasn't an unfair bet.
So yeah there is your slip up basing that entire claim on the mafia having a roleblocker, and then blaming me for voting BMM on the premise that there were apparently no other possibilities at that point.
Apollo's death is also an annoying WIFOM situation. Also hey, you're right why hasn't the mafia killed you by now? Of course, that goes for everyone else too. I expect if you're scum you just made that turnaround because Lightvayne voted for me. If he isn't your partner anyway. I don't really know at this point.